top of page
Search
Sohail Bhagat
Nov 1
3 min read

Imagine driving three hours just to see a specialist. Between taking time off work, finding transportation, and spending most of the day traveling, one appointment is an incredibly exhausting process. But that same appointment from home? No long drive, no missed day of work, and access to a doctor who might otherwise be out of reach. For rural communities that have long struggled with limited healthcare options, telehealth seems like an obvious improvement. But could making healthcare easier to reach also make it harder to keep close to home? 


The appeal of telehealth is easy to understand. Patients can speak with specialists who may not be available nearby, keep up with follow-up appointments, and get care that might otherwise require a long trip. But having these options doesn't necessarily mean everyone can use them. Between 2021 and 2023, just 26.3% of mental health visits in nonmetropolitan areas took place through telehealth, compared with 48.9% in metropolitan areas [1]. Those numbers don't tell the whole story, but they do raise questions about who is actually benefiting. For some patients, avoiding a long drive might mean dealing with unreliable internet, limited technology, or a lack of privacy instead. 


And even when a virtual appointment is possible, it isn't always what a patient wants or needs. Rural primary care patients have expressed the importance of being able to choose between virtual and in-person visits [2]. That choice matters. A quick video call might be perfect for discussing test results, but it won't work for every medical concern. Virtual primary care has shown promising results in some areas, although questions about safety and equity remain [3]. The goal should be to give patients more ways to receive care, not make them dependent on one. 


Then there's a concern that goes beyond the appointment itself. What happens to rural healthcare when more patients start turning to larger hospitals and healthcare systems outside their communities? While telehealth can make it easier to reach urban specialists, it can also shift visits and payments away from local providers. Virtual visits may replace care that patients would have received locally, while others can lead to additional visits with urban providers [4]. For clinics already operating with limited resources, that shift could create even more financial pressure. A patient might gain easier access to a specialist today, only to find fewer healthcare options close to home in the future. 


But telehealth doesn't have to work this way. Rather than pulling patients away from rural clinics, it can help those clinics offer more. Imagine a patient visiting a local practice, where staff help them connect with a specialist at a larger hospital. The specialist provides expertise that isn't available nearby, while the local team remains involved in testing, treatment, and follow-up. 


Partnerships between rural clinics and larger healthcare systems can make this kind of coordination possible [5]. In this case, telehealth isn't replacing rural healthcare. It's helping make it stronger. Rather than simply expanding virtual appointments, healthcare providers should focus on giving patients more options while supporting the local services they still depend on. Bringing a doctor closer through a screen shouldn't mean pushing the rest of a community's healthcare further away.


Designed by: Sohail Bhagat

Reviewed by: Manu Datta


References

[1] Decker, S. L. (2025). Use of telehealth in nonmetropolitan and metropolitan areas, United States 2021–2023. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. 

[2] Goldstein, K. M., et al. (2022). How can equitable video visit access be delivered in primary care? A qualitative study among rural primary care teams and patients. BMJ Open, 12(8), e062261. https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/12/8/e062261.

[3] Campbell, K., et al. (2023). The impact of virtual consultations on the quality of primary care: Systematic review. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 25, e48920. https://www.jmir.org/2023/1/e48920.

[4] Zhou, M., Li, X., & Burtch, G. (2024). Healthcare across boundaries: Urban-rural differences in the consequences of telehealth adoption. Information Systems Research, 35(3), 1092–1113. https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/10.1287/isre.2021.0380.

[5] U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2025, July 29). Developing a rural telehealth workflow and strategy. 



 
 
 

Imagine sitting in a doctor’s office, trying to understand a diagnosis, when your physician recommends a procedure. You have questions. The risks, the recovery, and whether there are other options. But, you hesitate to ask. The doctor has years of training, and you worry that questioning their recommendation might seem disrespectful. You agree, but does that agreement mean you felt comfortable making the decision?


The trust patients place in physicians gives their words significant influence. Those words can be the difference between yes and no, providing reassurance that may sway biases towards a life-or-death decision. While sometimes these recommendations can be helpful, they can also make a patient feel that the decision has already been made. From this, we can raise an important ethical question of how physicians can use their expertise to guide patients without pushing certain biases that influence patient priorities.


A physician’s recommendation can influence more than whether a patient accepts a treatment. It can dictate which option seems reasonable in the first place. For example, in an experiment involving 102 volunteers, researchers found that physicians’ recommendations influenced hypothetical treatment decisions, even when the recommendation favored an option that did not maximize health based on the information provided [1]. This study shows how recommendations can push people toward choices they would not otherwise make.


For example, imagine a physician recommends surgery because it offers a greater chance of long-term improvement, while a patient prioritizes avoiding a lengthy recovery because they care for a family member. If that responsibility never enters the conversation, the recommendation may overlook something central to the patient’s decision. The patient could agree that surgery sounds beneficial without feeling that it fits their circumstances.


However, sharing these concerns is not always easy. In a 2012 study, 1,340 adults responded to a hypothetical heart disease treatment scenario. About 70% preferred shared decision-making, but only 14% said they would express disagreement if their preferences conflicted with their physician’s recommendation [2]. Among participants unwilling to disagree, 47.2% feared being viewed as a difficult patient [2]. These findings suggest that even though patients want a voice in medical decisions, it can be hindered by a fear of how disagreement will be received. 


This makes it difficult to assume that a patient’s agreement reflects their priorities, which. This becomes especially problematic when patients are solelyentirely responsible for challenging recommendations. Physicians must approach these situations by presenting all reasonable options without bias and fairly, actively inviting concerns and attending to the patient’s priorities rather than waiting for the patient to challenge their advice.


Cultural perspectives can further shape how patients perceive their interactions with doctors and the doctor's overall role in the patient-doctor relationship. Through a systematic review of 20 qualitative studies involving 675 participants examining shared decision-making among Asian Americans, it was shown that medical authority, preserving harmony, and family involvement influenced some patients’ decisions. Some patients valued participation while preferring to leave the final decision to their physician [3].


These findings show why physicians should strive to understand the relationship a patient wants and their priorities within their medical care. One patient may welcome a strong recommendation, while others may want time to compare options with their family. Doctors must respect these differences and understand the individual rather than assuming the ideal medical decision. Choosing to rely on a doctor’s judgment can reflect a patient’s wishes, but that choice should also be open to questions and reconsideration.


Physicians can address this tension by taking time to understand patient priorities and explaining their recommendations and the values they assume. When alternatives exist, they should discuss their benefits and limitations and ask what concerns the patient most before settling on a plan. A question such as “What about this option would be difficult for you?” may surface concerns that a simple request for agreement leaves unspoken.


A doctor’s recommendation will carry influence because patients depend on their expertise. That influence creates an immense responsibility for doctors to examine how personal assumptions enter the conversation and whether they have heard the patient’s priorities. Before interpreting “yes” as agreement, physicians should consider whether they have created enough space for the patient to say something else.


Designed by: Abbie Qiu

Reviewed by: Josh Devine


References

[1] Gurmankin, A. D., Baron, J., Hershey, J. C., & Ubel, P. A. (2002). The role of physicians’ recommendations in medical treatment decisions. Medical Decision Making, 22(3), 262–271.https://doi.org/10.1177/0272989X0202200314

[2] Adams, J. R., Elwyn, G., Légaré, F., & Frosch, D. L. (2012). Communicating with physicians about medical decisions: A reluctance to disagree. Archives of Internal Medicine, 172(15), 1184–1186.https://doi.org/10.1001/archinternmed.2012.2360

[3] Tan, N. Q. P., Maki, K. G., López-Olivo, M. A., Geng, Y., & Volk, R. J. (2023). Cultural influences on shared decision-making among Asian Americans: A systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative studies. Patient Education and Counseling, 106, 17–30.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pec.2022.10.350



 
 
 

Updated: Oct 29


If you are reading this right now, think back to when you were just a kid. No stress over midterms or getting a job, back when we had nap time in school. Recess with friends was the best memory of your life. Now think back to when you got sick as a kid. Besides your parents, another very important person who probably cared for you was your pediatrician. Children are our future in more ways than just healthcare. They are our future legislators, teachers, CEOs, presidents, and more. But they deserve adequate care now, not just for their future. Yet many kids worldwide lack access to proper healthcare. This disparity leaves our most vulnerable children unprotected and keeps them from reaching their full potential. Is it fair for a child to not have access to proper healthcare, simply due to their location, though?


Part of this inaccessibility stems from a worldwide shortage of pediatricians. Per 100,000 children, there are anywhere from 0.5 to 72 pediatricians. (1) There was also a correlation between each country's income level and the number of pediatricians it had. Higher-income countries had more pediatricians per patient, while lower-income countries had fewer. To put those numbers in context, though, even in the most densely populated areas for pediatricians, there wouldn’t even be a full pediatrician to treat 1000 kids. So, it’s no wonder more people lack access to proper child healthcare. Compare this range to the range of all physicians. Worldwide, there are, on average, 1.9 physicians per 1000 people. (2) It is a bit unfair to compare these two, as one is in the context of all people, and the other is specific to kids. Yet, even at a glance, the numbers show a clear gap. This is not to say other doctors are overly abundant. More physicians and medical staff are needed in many areas. But the extreme shortage of pediatricians worldwide is also worth noting.


From a cultural perspective, the lack of pediatricians in certain areas can also be explained. Many people hold strong cultural beliefs against Western medicine and instead opt for traditional medicine, such as herbs. That alone can lower the number of physicians in an area, not just pediatricians. But a widespread cultural practice, especially in Asia, Latin America, and Africa, is collectivism. (3) This idea holds that decisions are family-centered, meaning no separation of treatment by age group. If the whole family is treated together, there is no need for pediatricians, since pediatricians are specialists, not general practitioners or family medicine doctors. This can also lead to fewer pediatricians and, therefore, less adequate pediatric care worldwide. We should recognize the importance of pediatric care while staying mindful of the causes of these shortages, such as funding and cultural differences.


Pediatric patients are different from adults. They process pain differently, have different specific illnesses, and require special care so as not to scare them. So, they are essential to saving lives and helping our future. After all, when you first got the flu, a pediatrician was the perfect person to turn to.


Designed by: Benny Peng

Reviewed by: Abbie Qiu


References

[1] “Physicians (per 1,000 people) | Data.” World Bank Open Data, https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.MED.PHYS.ZS. Accessed 23 October 2026.

[2] “Where are the paediatricians? An international survey to understand the global paediatric workforce.” PMC, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6361365/. Accessed 23 October 2026.

[3] Williams, Kesha Morant. “Collectivist Culture | Definition, Countries & Examples - Lesson.” Study.com, https://study.com/academy/lesson/collectivist-culture-definition-examples.html. Accessed 23 October 2026.




 
 
 

DMEJ

   Duke Medical Ethics Journal   

bottom of page