top of page
Search

What does it mean to heal? Is healing being prescribed a two-week course of antibiotics after an infection? Or is it reducing chronic stress through diet and lifestyle changes? The definition of healing morphs across cultures, opening up new ways of understanding medicine.


Cleveland Clinic describes the primary focus of modern Western medicine, or allopathic medicine, as “curing a disease [and] managing symptoms” [1]. Notably, allopathic medicine emphasizes specificity. Doctors specialize in particular organ systems, while treatments such as drugs and surgery target specific problems within those systems [2]. In this way, Western medicine often hones in on acute treatment, providing solutions to immediate or localized health problems. Rather than looking at every aspect of a patient’s life at once, allopathy takes a focused approach to diagnosing and treating a particular physiological issue [2, 3].


Consider joint replacement surgery. If a patient has a severely damaged joint, the procedure can replace it with an artificial one [4]. While the surgery directly addresses the damaged joint, recovery can still require months of physical rehabilitation and lifestyle adjustments [4]. This example illustrates how treatment is only one component of the broader healing process. Although Western medicine is sometimes criticized for focusing primarily on symptoms rather than their underlying causes, its specialized approach can be essential for addressing acute illnesses.


Yet, healing can extend beyond the sole intention of treating or eliminating disease. The Western Journal of Medicine states that “[holistic medicine] addresses the psychological, familial, societal, ethical and spiritual as well as biological dimensions of health and illness” [5]. Through this lens, healing goes beyond physical well-being and considers the many elements that shape an individual’s health.


One example is Ayurveda, a medical tradition that originated thousands of years ago in South Asia [6]. The word Ayurveda literally translates to “the study of life” [6]. A key principle of Ayurveda is that everything in the universe is interconnected, emphasizing the importance of balance [6, 7]. Its emphasis is not solely on the physical state of an individual, but also on environmental and lifestyle factors that may contribute to disharmony [7]. Ayurvedic practices can therefore emphasize alleviating stress, improving nutrition, establishing daily routines, and maintaining balance within the body and mind [6]. However, Ayurveda also demonstrates why traditional practices must be approached thoughtfully. Some botanical and mineral-based medicines can carry unintended risks, including heavy metal poisoning [6]. Nevertheless, the broader principles of Ayurveda offer another perspective on health by encouraging us to consider the individual beyond a single symptom or diagnosis.


Perhaps the most interesting possibility lies not in choosing between these two perspectives, but in understanding what each can contribute to patient care. Modern medicine provides interventions that can be essential for treating acute illnesses and injuries, while holistic practices highlight factors such as nutrition, stress, lifestyle, and overall well-being. These approaches do not have to be mutually exclusive; rather, they can illustrate different dimensions of health.


Ultimately, healing may not have one universal definition. By looking across cultures and medical traditions, we can begin to see that the way we define healing is shaped not only by biology, but also by how we understand the relationship between the body, mind, environment, and society.


Designed by: Nikhil Skandan

Reviewed by: Aman Maredia


References

[1] Cleveland Clinic. (2025, May 1). Western medicine. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/articles/22835-western-medicine

[2] Global Autoimmune Institute. (2021, January 28). Explained: Holistic vs. modern Western medicine. https://www.autoimmuneinstitute.org/articles/explained-holistic-vs-modern-western-medicine/ 

[3] Pizzorno J. (2016). Can We Say "Cure"?. Integrative medicine (Encinitas, Calif.), 15(5), 8–12.

[4] Cleveland Clinic. (2025, November 11). Knee replacement. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/8512-knee-replacement

[5] Gordon J. S. (1982). Holistic medicine: advances and shortcomings. The Western journal of medicine, 136(6), 546–551.

[7] Cleveland Clinic. (2025, December 19). What is Ayurveda and does it work? https://health.clevelandclinic.org/what-is-ayurveda

 
 
 


The tension between the values of autonomy and safety have been a major debate topic in the field of medical ethics. This tension applies to debates about guardianship, which is when a court appoints a person to make and supervise personal, day-to-day decisions, including medical decisions, for another person [1]. Guardianship is granted when the supervisee is deemed unable to independently manage their own lives [2]. 

Addiction can greatly impact a person’s ability to make sound, well-informed decisions about their health, finances, and everyday responsibilities [3]. Although substance use by itself does not necessarily mean someone lacks legal capacity, long-term or severe addiction can weaken judgment, memory, impulse control, and risk awareness [3]. When these effects begin to hinder a person’s ability to care for themselves or handle essential obligations, courts may consider whether legal measures, such as guardianship, are appropriate [3]. 

Guardianship is a controversial power because on one hand it helps protect people from themselves, but on the other hand it reduces their autonomy and has a risk for abuse. Courts try to navigate the line between this tension by trying to choose the least restrictive measures that can effectively protect someone, which means they typically will not order absolute guardianship lightly [3]. 

One of the most controversial aspects of guardianship is that it allows one to make medical decisions for another person [1]. Since addiction tends to have a high co-occurrence with psychiatric illnesses, this means that in a scenario of guardianship the guardian can force another person into receiving antipsychotic medications and electroconvulsive therapy [4-5]. Some argue that these restrictive measures can further the stigma around mental illness and addiction, and additionally weaken their ability to develop the competencies needed to re-integrate back into broader society after a mental health crisis [5]. 

But if we got rid of guardianship, what should society do if an addict is a clear danger to themselves? One alternative is involuntary commitment, where an addict is forced into a treatment facility, either short term or long term [6]. This could help protect the addict during a crisis, without needing a guardian to make their decisions long term. However, a problem with this is that once the rehab is completed the patient has a high risk of relapse, with 40–60% of individuals treated for a substance use disorder relapsing at some point [7]. This means that involuntary commitment alone is not effective for everyone long term, meaning further interventions like guardianship might be necessary for some. 

Overall, guardianship in the case of addiction is a contested issue that does not have a clear solution. Our government needs to find a healthy balance between protecting individual liberties while also protecting individual and societal safety. As a last resort, guardianship in some capacity seems to be necessary, but with strong safeguards against abuse and with the goal to make it temporary. 


Designed by: Vedant Patel

Reviewed by: Vedant Patel


References

[1] Moye, J. (2005). Guardianship and Conservatorship. In Evaluating Competencies (Vol. 16, pp. 309–389). Kluwer Academic Publishers. https://doi.org/10.1007/0-306-47922-2_8

[2] Nwakasi, C., & Restorick Roberts, A. (2018). CHALLENGES OF ADULT GUARDIANSHIP. Innovation in Aging, 2(suppl_1), 525–525. https://doi.org/10.1093/geroni/igy023.1940

[3] Casey, R. (2026, March 11). Guardianship and Addiction: What the Courts Consider. Robinson & Casey, PLLC. https://robinsoncasey.com/guardianship-and-addiction-what-the-courts-consider/

[4] Avramut, M. (2024). Mental illness and addiction . EBSCO Information Services, Inc. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/health-and-medicine/mental-illness-and-addiction

[5] Salzman, Leslie. (2011). Guardianship for persons with mental illness a legal and appropriate alternative. Saint Louis University Journal of Health Law & Policy, 4(2), 279-330.

[6] NC DHHS: Involuntary Commitments. (n.d.). Www.ncdhhs.gov. https://www.ncdhhs.gov/ivc

[7] Estrellado, N. (2024, July 24). National Statistics on Relapse Rates for Various Addictions - Addiction Group. Addiction Group. https://www.addictiongroup.org/resources/relapse-rates-statistics/

 
 
 
Julia Williams
Apr 19
3 min read


Addiction is a complex, chronic disorder that can affect individuals for long periods of time. Relapse rates are high with studies showing that 40-60% of individuals relapse within the first year following treatment [2]. Not only does addiction take a toll on the individual and their close friends and family, addiction is an economic burden in regards to healthcare system costs and workforce productivity. The opioid crisis alone has cost the U.S. around $1 trillion between 2001 and 2017 and costs employers an estimated $18 billion annually [1]. One of the greatest challenges in addiction treatment is relapse, which can occur even after periods of progress and stability. The identification of warning signs to allow for early intervention is crucial for effective treatment. Current treatment is limited in that it causes delayed intervention, relies on subjective self-reporting, and is embedded with recall bias [1,2]. When considering how to better treat addiction, finding ways to improve the accuracy of relapse prediction is extremely important. Relapse prediction is the process of recognizing warning signs that a person in recovery may be at risk of relapse and intervening before it happens. 


AI has become a common tool in healthcare, such as with cancer diagnosis, but its potential in early detection of relapse is quite promising. One study shows how a hybrid AI and machine-learning model achieved 99.75% accuracy in identifying risk factors associated with diagnosing Internet addiction [1]. AI can use common patterns in behavior, physiology, and patient history to estimate relapse risk [3]. Through collection of real-time data using phones and wearables (such as smart watches), information on mood, sleep quality, mobility, environment, stress, and other physiological metrics can be continuously monitored [2,4]. Additionally, AI models can detect less obvious warning signs like changes in daily routines, decreased social interaction, and irregular sleep [3]. Making use of these metrics, AI can be used to create individualized risk profiles, detect windows of relapse risk, and send alerts for intervention [5].


With AI’s potential for big data analysis and pattern recognition, real-time predictions can be relayed to clinicians and recovery support systems, allowing them to act proactively [3,4]. This opens up the possibility for anticipatory care models and tailored interventions, such as peer support systems and clinician outreach. Preventing relapse before it occurs allows for reinforcement of healthy coping strategies and behavioral cues that might help establish these supportive routines long-term, decreasing future relapse risk. 


AI models can also deliver personalized interactions that offer psychoeducation, coping strategies, and continuous support especially in times of emergency [1]. The advanced natural language processing capabilities of AI models may be able to address accessibility barriers and biases in traditional mental health care, though concerns persist regarding the accuracy of AI in simulating human-like interactions and the therapeutic relationship [1].


Although AI can be a very effective tool to detect potential relapses, AI alone will not comprehensively tackle addiction. Additionally, with the introduction of AI-based monitoring, there are various ethical and privacy concerns to address. To move forward with using this technology in relapse intervention, we must consider the data privacy risks and concerns about surveillance and potential data misuse [3]. Also, AI models must include data from a wide variety of sociocultural environments to prevent underrepresentation of certain populations [3]. 


AI has the potential to transform addiction care by shifting treatment from reactive to proactive. By utilizing real-time data and pattern recognition, periods of elevated relapse risk can be predicted and timely support can be administered. While there is still a long way to the practical implementation of AI in addiction relapse treatment, this technology is promising to improve long-term recovery outcomes from addiction.


Designed by: Jimin Lee

Reviewed by: Wendy House


References: 

[1] Khakpaki, A., & Sepehri, H. (2025, July 24). Ai in addiction: Harnessing technology for diagnosis, prevention, and recovery: A narrative review. Addiction and Substance Abuse. https://www.probiologists.com/article/ai-in-addiction-harnessing-technology-for-diagnosi s-prevention-and-recovery-a-narrative-review 

[2] Mirian Akujuobi, O., Chuks Azu, J., Uzoigwe, Z., & Nelyn Akunna, O. (2025). Digital Therapeutics and AI-Assisted Monitoring for Relapse Prevention in Substance Use Disorders. Healthcare Studies, 3(1), 21–29. https://doi.org/ 10.58612/hs314 

[3] Suva, M., & Bhatia, G. (2024, August 31). Artificial Intelligence in addiction: Challenges and opportunities. Indian journal of psychological medicine. 

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11572328/ 

[4] Barndollar, H. (2025, November 4). Ai could predict when someone is going to relapse on opioids. Governing. 

https://www.governing.com/artificial-intelligence/ai-could-predict-when-someone-is-goin g-to-relapse-on-opioids 

[5] Malhotra, D. K. (2022, March 20). The role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in assisting applied natya therapy for relapse prevention in de-addiction. SpringerLink. 

https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-98404-5_28

 
 
 

DMEJ

   Duke Medical Ethics Journal   

bottom of page