top of page
Search

When is a patient’s death morally acceptable? Are some lives no longer worth living? These questions lack an easy answer, which is why euthanasia has been and still is a controversial issue with no worldwide consensus. Euthanasia (or otherwise referred to as physician-assisted suicide or medical aid in dying) is the act of a physician directly killing or aiding in the death of a patient. It is done with the consent of the patient, who typically is suffering immensely, often due to terminal illness [1]. Due to the consequential nature of such an act, euthanasia has strong support as well as strong opposition worldwide. Proponents of euthanasia argue that it gives a patient autonomy and dignity by allowing them to choose to not endure unnecessary suffering. Opponents of euthanasia argue that it violates a person’s moral worth and a physician’s duty. They also express concern over potential abuses that could arise from establishing the boundaries for when euthanasia is appropriate. Both of these views have a diverse representation across the globe, with many factors causing the divide.


One such factor that heavily sways the opinion on euthanasia is religion. The Roman Catholic Church, the largest religious institution in the world, officially condemns euthanasia as “murder gravely contrary to the dignity of the human person and to the respect due to the living God, his Creator” [2]. This opinion is mostly echoed across the wider Christian community as well as other religious groups like Islam and Judaism [3]. Despite the wide diversity of beliefs among these groups, what generally unites them against euthanasia is the belief that death should ultimately be placed in God’s hands and not be decided by a person when it is not necessary. 


The lack of this belief is often why secular societies tend to be more open to euthanasia [4], but contrary to what might be expected, there is not a clear and distinct correlation between a country’s religious status and its laws on euthanasia. While euthanasia is largely permitted in secular countries like the Netherlands, Belgium, and Spain [5], it is banned in other secular countries like China [6]. Similarly, religious countries differ on euthanasia legislation, with countries like Afghanistan and the Philippines banning euthanasia [7], while others like Colombia permit it [8]. 


It is also important to note that the degree to which euthanasia is allowed varies widely. Some allow for physicians to directly administer a lethal injection, while others may require that the patient does the final act by a direct action like pressing a button. It can also vary a lot when it comes to the conditions that a patient must meet for euthanasia to be granted. Countries tend to mandate that a patient faces a certain death in the near future, as in the United States, but some have looser standards, even allowing euthanasia for mental illness in rare cases [9]. 


The inconsistency globally in when euthanasia is allowed is likely to give great pause for anyone considering this issue. We as humans pretty much unanimously agree that some suicides are wrong, but it is daunting to properly draw the line. Despite the gravity of this task, countries worldwide are now progressively gravitating towards legalizing euthanasia [10]. Whether this is indicative of an advancement in ethics is unclear. Unlike the scientific aspects of medicine, medical ethics don’t inevitably get better over time. The change in attitudes on euthanasia might be here to stay, but it is likely people thought the same of eugenics in the 19th and 20th centuries. Only time will tell what the world will think of euthanasia in years to come. 


Designed by: Isaac Kang

Reviewed by: Aiden Chun


References

[1] Government of the Netherlands. (n.d.). Is euthanasia legal in the Netherlands? https://www.government.nl/themes/family-health-and-care/euthanasia/is-euthanasia-allowed

[2] Catholic Church. (n.d.). I. Respect for human life. Vatican. https://www.vatican.va/content/catechism/en/part_three/section_two/chapter_two/article_5/i_respect_for_human_life.index.html

[3] Pew Research Center. (2013, November 21). Religious groups’ views on end-of-life issues. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2013/11/21/religious-groups-views-on-end-of-life-issues

[4] Grove, G. L., Lovell, M., Hughes, I., & Best, M. (2026). Conceptions of medical assistance in dying and euthanasia: A literature review on the role of religious affiliation and religiosity. Journal of Religion and Health. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-026-02607-4

[5] Reuters. (2025, June 20). The legal status of assisted dying in different countries. https://www.reuters.com/world/legal-status-assisted-dying-different-countries-2024-11-12/

[6] Wang, Y., Zhang, H., Zhang, Z., Gu, Y., & Shao, F. (2022). Assisted suicide and euthanasia: A comparative analysis of Dutch and East Asian cases. The American Journal of Bioethics, 22(2), 74–76. https://doi.org/10.1080/15265161.2021.2013986

[7] AACC Secretariat for Research and Development. (2022). Right to life (as of December 2020). Constitutional Court of Korea. https://docs-venice.coe.int/CoCentre/AACC-Right-to-Life-2022.pdf

[8] Looi, M.-K. (2024, October 30). Assisted dying laws around the world. The BMJ, 387, q2385. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2385

[9] Sherwood, H. (2024, May 16). Dutch woman, 29, granted euthanasia approval on grounds of mental suffering. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/society/article/2024/may/16/dutch-woman-euthanasia-approval-grounds-of-mental-suffering

[10] Blaakman, S. (2025, September 11). Euthanasia legislation in the EU. European Parliamentary Research Service. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/thinktank/en/document/EPRS_BRI%282025%29775914



 
 
 

What makes someone feel safe enough to ask for help? For someone experiencing depression or anxiety, that answer may depend on who offers care and how it is provided. In Zimbabwe, the Friendship Bench brings psychological support to wooden benches outside primary care clinics, where trained community health workers help patients work through their worries and concerns [1]. Many community health workers consist of older women whom patients tend to call grandmothers, and their role raises an important question for medicine: how can community relationships become part of effective care [2]?


BRINGING MENTAL HEALTHCARE INTO THE COMMUNITY

The Friendship Bench was developed specifically to target gaps in access to mental healthcare. Its workers use problem-solving therapy to help patients identify their most pressing concerns and develop practical steps to address them [1]. Patients then take an active role in deciding what to do next. Through this approach, it places support within an already existing community setting while expanding who can participate in providing mental healthcare. It also encourages us to consider how the settings and relationships surrounding treatment can influence a patient’s willingness to seek help.


HOW CULTURE SHAPES LANGUAGE AND TRUST

Having a cultural understanding can shape even the language of care. In the Harare communities studied, kufungisisa, a Shona expression translated as “thinking too much,” describes emotional distress involving too much worry and rumination [2]. The program incorporated this language into its screening approach. Interviews also suggested that workers’ maturity, community standing, and shared life experiences helped establish trust; patients sometimes described them in familial terms [2]. These findings suggest that culturally responsive care can include recognizing familiar expressions of suffering and the various relationships through which people feel comfortable discussing them. A patient’s understanding of their distress deserves a place in the conversation about treatment.


WHAT THE RESEARCH SHOWS

Clinical research supports the program’s promise as well. A 2016 randomized trial enrolled 573 adults across 24 clinics in Harare. After six months, 13.7% of participants receiving the Friendship Bench intervention met the study’s threshold for depressive symptoms, compared with 49.9% receiving enhanced usual care [3]. However, the study looked at a package that included problem-solving therapy and optional peer support, so it cannot suggest how much of the improvement came specifically from cultural familiarity [3].


SUPPORTING THE PEOPLE WHO PROVIDE CARE

Community caregiving also carries ethical responsibilities. A 2023 implementation study found that workers felt overwhelmed by complex cases and identified feedback and incentives as important to program delivery [4]. The model includes supervision and referral pathways for people needing a higher level of care [4]. Communities contributing their knowledge and labor deserve consistent investment in training and support. Recognizing the value of these workers should also include making sure they have the resources to care for others safely.


LESSON FOR HEALTHCARE AROUND THE WORLD

The Friendship Bench offers a perspective on medicine in which clinical methods and community relationships coexist. Other healthcare systems can learn from its attention to whom patients trust and how they describe suffering. Adapting that approach requires listening to the communities a service intends to reach. When a patient’s cultural knowledge helps shape care, medicine can become more approachable for the people it serves.


Designed by: Poorvaja Chandramouli

Reviewed by: Gage Gruett


References

{1] Chibanda, D., Bowers, T., Verhey, R., Rusakaniko, S., Abas, M., Weiss, H. A., & Araya, R. (2015). The Friendship Bench programme: A cluster randomised controlled trial of a brief psychological intervention for common mental disorders delivered by lay health workers in Zimbabwe. International Journal of Mental Health Systems, 9, Article 21. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13033-015-0013-y⁠

[2] Abas, M., Bowers, T., Manda, E., Cooper, S., Machando, D., Verhey, R., Lamech, N., Araya, R., & Chibanda, D. (2016). ‘Opening up the mind’: Problem-solving therapy delivered by female lay health workers to improve access to evidence-based care for depression and other common mental disorders through the Friendship Bench Project in Zimbabwe. International Journal of Mental Health Systems, 10, Article 39. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13033-016-0071-9⁠

[3] Chibanda, D., Weiss, H. A., Verhey, R., Simms, V., Munjoma, R., Rusakaniko, S., Chingono, A., Munetsi, E., Bere, T., Manda, E., Abas, M., & Araya, R. (2016). Effect of a primary care-based psychological intervention on symptoms of common mental disorders in Zimbabwe: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA, 316(24), 2618–2626. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2016.19102⁠

[4] Chitiyo, C., Verhey, R., Mboweni, S. N., Healey, A., Chibanda, D., Araya, R., & Wagenaar, B. H. (2023). Applying the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research to optimize implementation strategies for the Friendship Bench psychological intervention in Zimbabwe. Global Implementation Research and Applications, 3(3), 245–258. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43477-023-00093-4⁠



 
 
 

A patient leaves the hospital with instructions to make a follow-up appointment, pick up a prescription, and return for testing. The nearest provider is far away, the patient has no reliable transportation, and the local clinic does not offer the needed service. The patient may be medically stable enough to leave the hospital, but that does not necessarily mean the next steps are safe or realistic. What responsibility does the hospital have for care after discharge?


Distance, provider shortages, and limited local services can make follow-up difficult in rural communities. A study of primary care access in West Virginia found geographic and socioeconomic disparities, especially in the state’s rural southern counties [1]. A RAND report describes related challenges, including workforce shortages, transportation barriers, limited infrastructure, and gaps in broadband access [2]. West Virginia illustrates barriers that rural patients elsewhere may also face.


Federal rules require hospitals to involve patients in discharge planning. When a discharge planning evaluation is performed, the hospital must assess the patient’s likely need for post-hospital services and determine whether appropriate services are available and accessible [3]. Meeting this assessment requirement is the minimum. A fair discharge also requires acting on what the assessment finds.

This is an issue of justice. Patients should not have fewer opportunities to recover because they live far from a provider or lack transportation. Giving everyone the same instructions is not enough when some patients face greater barriers. A fair discharge process should account for those differences and help patients access the care they need.


Research on hospital discharge shows why the transition home deserves attention, while also showing the limits of current evidence. A systematic review and network meta-analysis of 126 randomized trials involving 97,408 participants found that some transitional care approaches were associated with lower odds of hospital readmission. However, the review did not find significant improvements in primary care or outpatient visits [4]. Interviews with older adults recovering from trauma in rural areas found that most felt prepared for discharge and had social support, yet geography and transportation remained major barriers to recovery [5]. Understanding the instructions, then, does not guarantee that a patient can get the care they need.


An ethics of care framework offers another way to think about the issue. It focuses on relationships and interdependence, and asks what responsibilities arise when people depend on others for care. Quilliam and colleagues argue that rural healthcare access is shaped by relationships among patients, providers, and communities [6]. In discharge planning, this means involving patients in decisions and taking their preferences and circumstances seriously. Staff should ask about transportation, distance, and local services, then work with the patient to identify a realistic option. Telehealth may help some patients, but limited broadband can make it unavailable to others [2].


Sometimes there is no accessible provider or transportation option. In that case, the hospital should discuss with the patient and care team how the missing service affects the safety of the transition. They should consider whether the discharge plan needs to change and set out what the patient should do and whom to contact if care falls through. A workable plan should confirm that a provider can deliver the needed service, arrange an appointment when feasible, and identify who is responsible for follow-up.

Patients have a role in managing their care, but they should not be blamed for barriers outside their control. Hospitals cannot create services that do not exist. They can assess foreseeable barriers, involve patients in planning, and respond when the available options do not meet the patient’s needs. When follow-up care is part of treatment, a fair discharge requires more than documenting that services are inaccessible. It requires a clear decision about how the patient’s care will continue.


Designed by: Sohail Bhagat Reviewed by: Ayan Jung


References 

[1] Hong, I., Wilson, B., Gross, T., Conley, J., & Powers, T. (2023). Challenging terrains. Socio-spatial analysis of primary health care access disparities in West Virginia. Applied Spatial Analysis and Policy, 16, 141–161. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12061-022-09472-0.

[2] RAND. (2025). Developing a Research Agenda to Improve Rural Health Access and Quality in West Virginia. https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RRA4484-1.html.

[3] 42 C.F.R. § 482.43. Condition of participation: Discharge planning. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-G/part-482/subpart-C/section-482.43.

[4] Tyler, N., Hodkinson, A., Planner, C., et al. (2023). Transitional care interventions from hospital to community to reduce health care use and improve patient outcomes. A systematic review and network meta-analysis. JAMA Network Open, 6(11), e2344825. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.44825.

[5] Duchin, E. R., Neisinger, L., Reed, M. J., Gause, E., Sharninghausen, J., & Pham, T. (2022). Perspectives on recovery from older adult trauma survivors living in rural areas. Trauma Surgery & Acute Care Open, 7(1), e000881. https://doi.org/10.1136/tsaco-2022-000881.

[6] Quilliam, C., Glenister, K., Ervin, K., & Weller-Newton, J. (2023). Revisiting rural healthcare access through Held’s ethics of care. Social Theory & Health, 21, 178–193. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41285-022-00181-9.

 
 
 

DMEJ

   Duke Medical Ethics Journal   

bottom of page